| Blue Cast | Purple Cast | |
| Nora Brosius | Margie | Emma Schat |
| Robyn Nutter | Ellen | Lilly Cummings |
| Eva Hendren | Annabelle | Paelyn Miller |
| Emily O’Connor | Bombalarina | Leah Davidson |
| Leah Davidson | Pollyanna | Emily O’Connor |
| Janis Taylor | Nutcracker | Anaiety McPherson |
| Landon Seale | Tom Sawyer | Landon Seale |
| Emily Yalnazov | Dorothy | Abigail Click |
| Truman Townsend | Dr. Doolittle | Adrian Mays |
| Harlyn Willis | Velveteen Rabbit | Olivia Birdwell |
| Charlotte Weitzel | Amy March | Sophie Holbrook |
| Mya Yingst | Little Match Girl | Julia Crawford |
| Braydon Ward | Jim Young/Philip Brantley | Jayden Marcum |
| Merial Willis | Della Young | Eloise Murphy |
| Mary Kathryn Eidson | Book Fairy | Sophie Tatum |
| Chad Hembree | Ebeneezer Scrooge | Chad Hembree |
Enchanted Bookshop Christmas Cast 2023