Presented by Spotlight on Faith • By Barbara Robinson • Directed by Jazzlyn Threlkeld, John Bailey, John Paul Ramsay, and Chad Hembree
| Character | Cast Member |
|---|---|
| Father | Samuel Bruce |
| The Fireman | Samuel Bruce |
| Mother | Kristen Ramsay |
| Beth | Lily Ramsay |
| Charlie | Joel Ramsay |
| Ralph | Ganon Denny |
| Imogene | Ava Howell |
| Leroy | Hayden McIntosh |
| Claude | Luca Swack |
| Ollie | Eden Minter |
| Gladys | Emma Wehrly |
| Alice | Avery Boggess |
| Mrs. Armstrong | Jennifer Woodruff |
| Mrs. Slocum | Alyssa Graft |
| Mrs. Clark | Alexis Graft |
| Mrs. Clausing | Christy Graft |
| Mrs. McCarthy | Dana Hendren |
| Maxine | Lucy Ramsay |
| Elmer | Patrick Beaulieu |
| Hobie | Ella Graft |
| David | Isaac Beaulieu |
| Beverly | Nina Ramsay |
| Shirley | Harper Naugle |
| Juanita | Heidi Reeder |
| Doris | Alaina Hendren |
| Reverend Hopkins | Chad Hembree |
Support Roles — Crew, Angel Choir & Shepherds
Ava Lamb, Sophia Umberger, Amelia McIntosh, Jennifer Winkler, Nora Swack, Olivia Gilliam, Emma Gilliam, Winter Primrose, Lennox Voiles, and Elias Ramsay.
The Best Christmas Pageant Ever. By Barbara Robinson. Presented by Spotlight on Faith. Directed by Jazzlyn Threlkeld, John Bailey, John Paul Ramsay, and Chad Hembree. Performances December 4–13, 2026 at The Spotlight Playhouse, 214 Richmond Rd, Berea, KY. Licensed by Concord Theatricals.